| Everton | Notts County | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GK | Robert Smalley | GK | Jack Holland | ||
| RB | Alec Dick | RB | Frank Guttridge | ||
| LB | Nick Ross | LB | Tom McLean | ||
| RH | Johnny Holt | RH | George H Brown | ||
| CH | Alex McKinnon | CH | Ben Warburton | ||
| LH | George Dobson | LH | Alf Shelton | ||
| OR | George Fleming | OR | Bill Hodder | ||
| IR | David Waugh | IR | Ted Harker | ||
| CF | Billy Lewis | CF | Bob Jardine | ||
| IL | Edgar Chadwick | IL | Albert Moore | ||
| OL | George Farmer | OL | Edwin Wardle | ||
| Manager | Manager | ||||
| Walter E Barclay | Edwin Browne | ||||