| Notts County | Everton | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GK | George Toone | GK | Robert Smalley | ||
| RB | Tom McLean | RB | Andrew Hannah | ||
| LB | James McMillan | LB | Dan Doyle | ||
| RH | Sandy Ferguson | RH | Charlie Parry | ||
| CH | David Calderhead | CH | Johnny Holt | ||
| LH | Alf Shelton | LH | George Farmer | ||
| OR | William 'Tich' Smith | OR | Alex Latta | ||
| IR | Teddy May | IR | David Kirkwood | ||
| CF | Jimmy Oswald | CF | Fred Geary | ||
| IL | John Oswald | IL | Edgar Chadwick | ||
| OL | Harry Daft | OL | Alf Milward | ||
| Manager | Manager | ||||
| Edwin Browne | Dick Molyneux | ||||