| Everton | Derby County | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GK | Dick Williams | GK | George Dockery | ||
| RB | Bob Kelso | RB | Jimmy Methven | ||
| LB | Bob Howarth | LB | Jonathan Staley | ||
| RH | Dickie Boyle | RH | Ernest Hickinbottom | ||
| CH | Johnny Holt | CH | Archie Goodall | ||
| LH | Billy Stewart | LH | Walter Roulstone | ||
| OR | Alex Latta | OR | John Allan | ||
| IR | Jack Bell | IR | Steve Bloomer | ||
| CF | Jack 'Skimmy' Southworth | CF | John Goodall | ||
| IL | Edgar Chadwick | IL | Johnny McMillan | ||
| OL | Alf Milward | OL | Thomas Towie | ||
| Manager | Manager | ||||
| Dick Molyneux | Board of Directors | ||||