| Everton | Grimsby Town | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GK | George Kitchen | GK | Martin Spendiff | ||
| RB | Sam Wolstenholme | RB | Bodge Mountain | ||
| LB | Walter Balmer | LB | Dave Gardner | ||
| RH | Jack Taylor | RH | Bill Hemmingfield | ||
| CH | Charles Clark | CH | Paddy Gray | ||
| LH | Walter Abbott | LH | Alf Nelmes | ||
| OR | Jack Sharp | OR | Harry Fletcher | ||
| IR | John Brearley | IR | George Spencer Harper | ||
| CF | Adam Bowman | CF | Bill Appleyard | ||
| IL | Paddy Sheridan | IL | Jimmy Long | ||
| OL | Jack Bell | OL | Harry Bertram Singleton | ||
| Manager | Manager | ||||
| William C Cuff | H N Hickson | ||||