| Sunderland | Notts County | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GK | Tom Naisby | GK | Matt 'Gunner' Reilly | ||
| RB | Ephraim 'Dusty' Rhodes | RB | Arthur Griffiths | ||
| LB | Tom Daykin | LB | Jack Montgomery | ||
| RH | Billy Farquhar | RH | Teddy Emberton | ||
| CH | William Fullarton | CH | Harry Mainman | ||
| LH | Alex Barrie | LH | Ben Craythorne | ||
| OR | Norman Brown | OR | Jerry Dean | ||
| IR | George Holley | IR | Percy Humphreys | ||
| CF | Billy Hogg | CF | Arthur Green | ||
| IL | Jimmy Hindmarsh | IL | Walter Tarplin | ||
| OL | Arthur Bridgett | OL | Ellis Gee | ||
| Manager | Manager | ||||
| Robert Kyle | Tom Harris | ||||