| Newcastle United | Manchester United | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GK | Jimmy Lawrence | GK | Harry Moger | ||
| RB | Billy McCracken | RB | Dick Holden | ||
| LB | Jack Carr | LB | Herbert Burgess | ||
| RH | Alec Gardner | RH | Dick Duckworth | ||
| CH | Finlay Speedie | CH | Charlie Roberts | ||
| LH | Colin Veitch | LH | Alex Bell | ||
| OR | Jock Rutherford | OR | Billy Meredith | ||
| IR | Jimmy Howie | IR | Alex Menzies | ||
| CF | Bill Appleyard | CF | Bill Berry | ||
| IL | Ronald Orr | IL | John Picken | ||
| OL | Bert Gosnell | OL | George Wall | ||
| Manager | Manager | ||||
| Frank Watt | Ernest Mangnall | ||||