| Everton | Middlesbrough | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GK | Billy Scott | GK | Tim Williamson | ||
| RB | William Stevenson | RB | Donald 'Slasher' McLeod | ||
| LB | Bob Balmer | LB | Jimmy Weir | ||
| RH | Val Harris | RH | Billy Barker | ||
| CH | Robert Young | CH | Andy Jackson | ||
| LH | Harry Makepeace | LH | William Duguid | ||
| OR | Arthur Berry | OR | James Peggie | ||
| IR | George Beare | IR | George Elliott | ||
| CF | Sandy Young | CF | Fred Pentland | ||
| IL | James Gourlay | IL | Samuel McClure | ||
| OL | Bob Turner | OL | Willie Davidson | ||
| Manager | Manager | ||||
| William C Cuff | Andy Walker | ||||