| Oldham Athletic | Sheffield United | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GK | Hugh McDonald | GK | Joe Lievesley | ||
| RB | Jimmy Hodson | RB | Bob Benson | ||
| LB | Steve Buxton | LB | Joe Brooks | ||
| RH | Hugh Moffatt | RH | Albert Sturgess | ||
| CH | David Walders | CH | Bernard Wilkinson | ||
| LH | David Wilson | LH | Albert Trueman | ||
| OR | Tommy Broad | OR | Ted Connor | ||
| IR | Tom Marrison | IR | Jim Simmons | ||
| CF | Evan Jones | CF | Joe Kitchen | ||
| IL | George 'Lady' Woodger | IL | Billy Peake | ||
| OL | Joe Donnachie | OL | Bobby Evans | ||
| Manager | Manager | ||||
| David Ashworth | John Nicholson | ||||