| Middlesbrough | Everton | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GK | Tim Williamson | GK | James Caldwell | ||
| RB | Donald 'Slasher' McLeod | RB | William Stevenson | ||
| LB | Jimmy Weir | LB | Jock Maconnachie | ||
| RH | William Duguid | RH | Val Harris | ||
| CH | Willie Carr | CH | Tommy Fleetwood | ||
| LH | Teddy Verrill | LH | Harry Makepeace | ||
| OR | Jock Stirling | OR | George Beare | ||
| IR | George Elliott | IR | Frank Jefferis | ||
| CF | Arthur Brown | CF | Tommy Browell | ||
| IL | Jimmy Windridge | IL | Frank Bradshaw | ||
| OL | Edmund Eyre | OL | Harold Uren | ||
| Manager | Manager | ||||
| Thomas H McIntosh | William C Cuff | ||||