| Newcastle United | Manchester City | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GK | Bill Bradley | GK | Jim Goodchild | ||
| RB | Robert Roxburgh | RB | Frank Thompson | ||
| LB | Frank Hudspeth | LB | James Calderwood | ||
| RH | Tom Curry | RH | Sammy Sharp | ||
| CH | Charlie Spencer | CH | Mickey Hamill | ||
| LH | Peter Mooney | LH | Charlie Pringle | ||
| OR | Jimmy Low | OR | Robert Etherington | ||
| IR | Willie Aitken | IR | Frank Roberts | ||
| CF | William Scott | CF | Tosh Johnson | ||
| IL | Tommy McDonald | IL | Horace Barnes | ||
| OL | Tom Mitchell | OL | Spud Murphy | ||
| Manager | Manager | ||||
| Frank Watt | Ernest Mangnall | ||||