| Everton | Sheffield United | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GK | Alfie Harland | GK | Charles Sutcliffe | ||
| RB | Jock McDonald | RB | Bill Cook | ||
| LB | Jack O'Donnell | LB | Ernest Milton | ||
| RH | William Brown | RH | Harry Pantling | ||
| CH | Neil McBain | CH | Seth King | ||
| LH | Hunter Hart | LH | George Green | ||
| OR | Sam Chedgzoy | OR | David Mercer | ||
| IR | Bobby Irvine | IR | Tommy Boyle | ||
| CF | Jimmy Broad | CF | Harry Johnson | ||
| IL | Fred Kennedy | IL | Billy Gillespie | ||
| OL | Alec Troup | OL | Fred Tunstall | ||
| Manager | Manager | ||||
| Thomas H McIntosh | John Nicholson | ||||