| Newcastle United | Leicester City | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GK | Albert McInroy | GK | Jimmy McLaren | ||
| RB | Jimmy Nelson | RB | Adam Black | ||
| LB | David Fairhurst | LB | George Dumbrell | ||
| RH | Roddie MacKenzie | RH | Norman Watson | ||
| CH | Dave Davidson | CH | Roger Heywood | ||
| LH | Sam Weaver | LH | George Ritchie | ||
| OR | Jimmy Boyd | OR | Hughie Adcock | ||
| IR | Jimmy Richardson | IR | Ernie Hine | ||
| CF | Jack Allen | CF | Arthur Chandler | ||
| IL | Ronnie Starling | IL | Arthur Lochhead | ||
| OL | Tommy Lang | OL | Len Barry | ||
| Manager | Manager | ||||
| Andy Cunningham | Peter Hodge | ||||