| Sheffield United | Newcastle United | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GK | Jack Kendall | GK | Mick Burns | ||
| RB | Jock Gibson | RB | Jimmy Nelson | ||
| LB | Harry Hooper | LB | Bob Thomson | ||
| RH | Harry Gooney | RH | Roddie MacKenzie | ||
| CH | Jim Holmes | CH | Dave Davidson | ||
| LH | Tom Johnson | LH | Sam Weaver | ||
| OR | Bunny Oxley | OR | Jimmy Boyd | ||
| IR | Bobby Barclay | IR | Ronnie Starling | ||
| CF | Jimmy Dunne | CF | Jimmy Richardson | ||
| IL | Jack Pickering | IL | Harry McMenemy | ||
| OL | Bert Oswald | OL | Tommy Lang | ||
| Manager | Manager | ||||
| Board of Directors | Andy Cunningham | ||||