| Sheffield Wednesday | Sheffield United | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GK | Jack Brown | GK | Jack Smith | ||
| RB | George Beeson | RB | Ernie Robinson | ||
| LB | Ernie Blenkinsop | LB | Charlie Wilkinson | ||
| RH | Alf Strange | RH | Ernie Jackson | ||
| CH | Tony Leach | CH | Jim Holmes | ||
| LH | Horace Burrows | LH | Harry Gooney | ||
| OR | Mark Hooper | OR | Bertie Williams | ||
| IR | Ronnie Starling | IR | Bobby Barclay | ||
| CF | Jack Ball | CF | Reg Baines | ||
| IL | Harry Burgess | IL | Bunny Oxley | ||
| OL | Ellis Rimmer | OL | Bert Oswald | ||
| Manager | Manager | ||||
| Rob Brown | Teddy Davison | ||||