| Everton | Grimsby Town | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GK | Ted Sagar | GK | George Tweedy | ||
| RB | Billy Cook | RB | Ned Vincent | ||
| LB | Jack Jones | LB | Ned Kelly | ||
| RH | Joe Mercer | RH | Alec Hall | ||
| CH | Tommy White | CH | Jack Hodgson | ||
| LH | Jock Thomson | LH | Teddy Buck | ||
| OR | Albert Geldard | OR | Jimmy Dyson | ||
| IR | Nat Cunliffe | IR | Jackie Bestall | ||
| CF | Dixie Dean | CF | Pat Glover | ||
| IL | Alex Stevenson | IL | Charlie Craven | ||
| OL | Torry Gillick | OL | Matt Moralee | ||
| Manager | Manager | ||||
| Selection Committee | Frank Womack | ||||