| Everton | Leicester City | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Ted Sagar | 1 | Sandy McLaren | ||
| 2 | Billy Cook | 2 | Dai Jones | ||
| 3 | Norman Greenhalgh | 3 | Maurice Reeday | ||
| 4 | Joe Mercer | 4 | Roger Heywood | ||
| 5 | Tommy Jones | 5 | Fred Sharman | ||
| 6 | Gordon Watson | 6 | Percy Grosvenor | ||
| 7 | Torry Gillick | 7 | Mal Griffiths | ||
| 8 | Stan Bentham | 8 | Sep Smith | ||
| 9 | Tommy Lawton | 9 | Jack Bowers | ||
| 10 | Alex Stevenson | 10 | Billy Coutts | ||
| 11 | Wally Boyes | 11 | Danny Liddle | ||
| Manager | Manager | ||||
| Selection Committee | Frank Womack | ||||