| Manchester City | Everton | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Bert Trautmann | 1 | Jimmy O'Neill | ||
| 2 | Bill Leivers | 2 | Eric Moore | ||
| 3 | Roy Little | 3 | Jimmy Tansey | ||
| 4 | Ken Barnes | 4 | Peter Farrell | ||
| 5 | Dave Ewing | 5 | Tommy E Jones | ||
| 6 | Roy Paul | 6 | Cyril Lello | ||
| 7 | Bill Spurdle | 7 | Brian Harris | ||
| 8 | Joe Hayes | 8 | Eddie Wainwright | ||
| 9 | Bobby Johnstone | 9 | Jimmy Harris | ||
| 10 | Jack Dyson | 10 | Wally Fielding | ||
| 11 | Roy Clarke | 11 | Tommy Eglington | ||
| Manager | Manager | ||||
| Les McDowall | Selection Committee | ||||