Wednesday 1958-01-08
| Cup and International Matches |
| FA Cup Round 3 | Venue |
Gate | Notes |
| D 3N | York City | 3 | 0 | Birmingham City | D 1 | Bootham Crescent | 19,750 | |
| Bottom, Wragg, Wilkinson | Lineups | | | | | |
| FA Cup Round 3 Replay |
Venue |
Gate |
Notes |
| D 1 | Aston Villa | 3 | 3 | Stoke City | D 2 | Villa Park | 38,939 | aet |
| Sewell, Lynn, Hitchens | Lineups | Coleman, Kelly, Oscroft | | | | |
| D 2 | Barnsley | 0 | 2 | Hull City | D 3N | Oakwell | 20,890 | |
| | Lineups | Clarke, Bulless | | | | |
| D 2 | Charlton Athletic | 1 | 0 | Huddersfield Town | D 2 | The Valley | 26,637 | |
| Ryan | Lineups | | | | | |
| D 1 | Everton | 3 | 1 | Sunderland | D 1 | Goodison Park | 56,952 | aet |
| Keeley 2, Hickson | Lineups | Fleming | | | | |
| D 3S | Southend United | 2 | 3 | Liverpool | D 2 | Roots Hall | 16,555 | |
| Molyneux OG, McCrory | Lineups | Molyneux, White, Rowley | | | | |
