| Everton | Newcastle United | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Albert Dunlop | 1 | Bryan Harvey | ||
| 2 | Alex Parker | 2 | Bill McKinney | ||
| 3 | John Bramwell | 3 | Alf McMichael | ||
| 4 | Jimmy Gabriel | 4 | Jackie Bell | ||
| 5 | Brian Labone | 5 | Bob Stokoe | ||
| 6 | Mick Meagan | 6 | George Luke | ||
| 7 | Mickey Lill | 7 | Gordon Hughes | ||
| 8 | Bobby Collins | 8 | George Eastham | ||
| 9 | Jimmy Harris | 9 | Len White | ||
| 10 | Roy Vernon | 10 | Ivor Allchurch | ||
| 11 | Tommy Ring | 11 | John Mitten | ||
| Manager | Manager | ||||
| Johnny Carey | Charlie Mitten | ||||