| Everton | Sheffield United | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Gordon West | 1 | Alan Hodgkinson | ||
| 2 | Tommy Wright | 2 | Len Badger | ||
| S1 | 3 | Ray Wilson | 3 | Bernard Shaw | |
| 4 | Jimmy Gabriel | 4 | Frank Barlow | ||
| 5 | Brian Labone | 5 | Ken Mallender | ||
| 6 | Brian Harris | 6 | Barry Wagstaff | ||
| 7 | Alex Scott | 7 | Alan Woodward | ||
| 8 | Alex Young | 8 | Tony Wagstaff | ||
| 9 | Fred Pickering | 9 | Mick Jones | ||
| 10 | Colin Harvey | 10 | Alan Birchenall | ||
| 11 | Derek Temple | 11 | Tom Fenoughty | ||
| Substitute | Substitute | ||||
| S1 | Sandy Brown | ||||
| Manager | Manager | ||||
| Harry Catterick | John Harris | ||||