| Everton | Sheffield United | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Neville Southall | 1 | Simon Tracey | ||
| 2 | Neil McDonald | 2 | Chris Wilder | ||
| 3 | Andy Hinchcliffe | 3 | David Barnes | ||
| S2 | 4 | Kevin Ratcliffe | S1 | 4 | Vinnie Jones |
| 5 | Dave Watson | 5 | Paul Beesley | ||
| 6 | Martin Keown | 6 | Colin Hill | ||
| 7 | Mike Milligan | S2 | 7 | Carl Bradshaw | |
| 8 | Stuart McCall | 8 | John Gannon | ||
| S1 | 9 | Graeme Sharp | 9 | Glyn Hodges | |
| 10 | Tony Cottee | 10 | Brian Deane | ||
| 11 | John Ebbrell | 11 | Ian Bryson | ||
| Substitute | Substitute | ||||
| S1 | Pat Nevin | S1 | Bob Booker | ||
| S2 | Mike Newell | S2 | Brian Marwood | ||
| Manager | Manager | ||||
| Howard Kendall | Dave Bassett | ||||