| Everton | Sheffield United | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GK | Neville Southall | GK | Alan Kelly | ||
| DR | Paul Holmes | DR | John Pemberton | ||
| DR | Andy Hinchcliffe | S2 | DR | Carl Bradshaw | |
| DR | Gary Ablett | DR | Tom Cowan | ||
| DR | Matt Jackson | S1 | DR | David Tuttle | |
| MD | John Ebbrell | MD | Willie Falconer | ||
| MD | Mark Ward | MD | Paul Rogers | ||
| S1 | MD | Peter Beagrie | MD | Mitch Ward | |
| S2 | AM | Graham Stuart | AM | Dane Whitehouse | |
| FD | Paul Rideout | FD | Jostein Flo | ||
| FD | Tony Cottee | FD | Andy Scott | ||
| Substitute | Substitute | ||||
| S1 | DR | Preki Radosavljevic | S1 | DR | Paul Beesley |
| S2 | FD | Stuart Barlow | S2 | FD | Alan Cork |
| Manager | Manager | ||||
| Howard Kendall | Dave Bassett | ||||