| Wimbledon | Sheffield United | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GK | Hans Segers | GK | Alan Kelly | ||
| DR | Warren Barton | DR | Carl Bradshaw | ||
| DR | Brian McAllister | DR | Kevin Gage | ||
| DR | John Scales | DR | Jonas Wirmola | ||
| DR | Scott Fitzgerald | DR | David Tuttle | ||
| DR | Vinnie Jones | DR | Paul Beesley | ||
| MD | Neal Ardley | MD | Chris Kamara | ||
| MD | Robbie Earle | S1 | MD | Willie Falconer | |
| S1 | AM | Steve Talboys | AM | Dane Whitehouse | |
| FD | John Fashanu | FD | Jostein Flo | ||
| FD | Dean Holdsworth | FD | Alan Cork | ||
| Substitute | Substitute | ||||
| S1 | AM | Gerald Dobbs | S1 | AM | Glyn Hodges |
| Manager | Manager | ||||
| Joe Kinnear | Dave Bassett | ||||