| Everton | Newcastle United | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GK | Neville Southall | GK | Mike Hooper | ||
| DR | Earl Barrett | DR | Barry Venison | ||
| DR | Andy Hinchcliffe | S1 | DR | Marc Hottiger | |
| DR | David Unsworth | DR | Robbie Elliott | ||
| DR | Gary Ablett | DR | Darren Peacock | ||
| DR | Dave Watson | DR | Steve Howey | ||
| MD | Barry Horne | MD | Paul Bracewell | ||
| MD | Joe Parkinson | MD | Rob Lee | ||
| AM | Graham Stuart | S2 | AM | Ruel Fox | |
| FD | Anders Limpar | FD | Paul Kitson | ||
| S1 | FD | Daniel Amokachi | FD | Peter Beardsley | |
| Substitute | Substitute | ||||
| S1 | MD | Tony Grant | S1 | MD | Lee Clark |
| WR | S2 | WR | Keith Gillespie | ||
| Manager | Manager | ||||
| Joe Royle | Kevin Keegan | ||||