| Everton | Barnsley |
|---|
| GK | Paul Gerrard | | GK | David Watson |
| DR | Andy Hinchcliffe | | DR | Darren Barnard |
| DR | Craig Short | | DR | Adie Moses |
| DR | Slaven Bilic | | DR | Arjan De Zeeuw |
| DR | Dave Watson | | DR | Peter Shirtliff |
| MD | Gary Speed | | MD | Darren Sheridan |
| S1 | MD | Danny Williamson | S2 | MD | Matty Appleby |
| MD | Nick Barmby | | MD | Neil Redfearn |
| MD | Graham Stuart | S3 | MD | Eric Tinkler |
| S2 | FD | Danny Cadamarteri | | FD | Andy Liddell |
| FD | Duncan Ferguson | S1 | FD | Ashley Ward |
| Substitute | Substitute |
|---|
| S1 | FD | Gareth Farrelly | S1 | FD | Georgi Hristov |
| S2 | MD | John Oster | S2 | MD | Clint Marcelle |
| AM | | S3 | AM | Martin Bullock |
| Manager | Manager |
|---|
| | Howard Kendall | | | Danny Wilson |