| Sheffield Wednesday | Everton |
|---|
| GK | Kevin Pressman | | GK | Paul Gerrard |
| DR | Ian Nolan | S2 | DR | Tony Thomas |
| DR | Des Walker | | DR | Andy Hinchcliffe |
| DR | Dejan Stefanovic | S1 | DR | Michael Ball |
| S1 | DR | Steve Nicol | | DR | Dave Watson |
| S2 | DR | Mark Pembridge | | DR | Slaven Bilic |
| MD | Wayne Collins | | MD | Danny Williamson |
| S3 | MD | Jim Magilton | | MD | Gary Speed |
| AM | Guy Whittingham | | AM | John Oster |
| WR | Benito Carbone | | WR | Graham Stuart |
| FD | Paolo Di Canio | | FD | Danny Cadamarteri |
| Substitute | Substitute |
|---|
| S1 | MD | Lee Briscoe | S1 | MD | Nick Barmby |
| S2 | DR | David Hirst | S2 | DR | Craig Short |
| S3 | | Adem Poric | | | |
| Manager | Manager |
|---|
| | David Pleat | | | Howard Kendall |