| Newcastle United | Everton |
|---|
| GK | Steve Harper | | GK | Tim Howard |
| S1 | DR | Jose Enrique | | DR | Tony Hibbert |
| DR | Danny Simpson | | DR | Leighton Baines |
| DR | Fabricio Coloccini | S1 | DR | Phil Neville |
| DR | Mike Williamson | | DR | Phil Jagielka |
| S2 | DR | Steven Taylor | | DR | Sylvain Distin |
| MD | Kevin Nolan | | MD | Mikel Arteta |
| MD | Cheick Tiote | S3 | MD | Leon Osman |
| AM | Jonas Gutierrez | | MD | Jack Rodwell |
| FD | Peter Lovenkrands | | FD | Louis Saha |
| S3 | FD | Leon Best | S2 | FD | Jermaine Beckford |
| Substitute | Substitute |
|---|
| S1 | FD | Shola Ameobi | S1 | DR | Johnny Heitinga |
| S2 | WR | Shane Ferguson | S2 | FD | Victor Anichebe |
| S3 | FD | Shefki Kuqi | S3 | DR | Seamus Coleman |
| Manager | Manager |
|---|
| | Alan Pardew | | | David Moyes |