| Everton | Watford |
|---|
| GK | Tim Howard | | GK | Heurelho Gomes |
| DR | Seamus Coleman | | DR | Allan Nyom |
| S1 | DR | Brendan Galloway | | DR | Jose Holebas |
| DR | John Stones | S1 | DR | Miguel Layun |
| DR | Phil Jagielka | | DR | Sebastian Prodl |
| MD | Tom Cleverley | | DR | Craig Cathcart |
| MD | James McCarthy | S2 | MD | Jose Manuel Jurado |
| MD | Gareth Barry | S3 | MD | Valon Behrami |
| MD | Ross Barkley | | MD | Etienne Capoue |
| S2 | WR | Kevin Mirallas | | AM | Ikechi Anya |
| S3 | FD | Romelu Lukaku | | FD | Troy Deeney |
| Substitute | Substitute |
|---|
| S1 | FD | Arouna Kone | S1 | DR | Juan Carlos Paredes |
| S2 | DR | Bryan Oviedo | S2 | FD | Odion Ighalo |
| S3 | MD | Steven Naismith | S3 | MD | Ben Watson |
| Manager | Manager |
|---|
| | Roberto Martinez | | | Quique Flores |