| Everton | Sheffield United | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GK | Jordan Pickford | GK | Aaron Ramsdale | ||
| S1 | DR | Mason Holgate | DR | George Baldock | |
| DR | Lucas Digne | DR | Enda Stevens | ||
| DR | Seamus Coleman | DR | Jack Robinson | ||
| DR | Michael Keane | DR | John Egan | ||
| DR | Ben Godfrey | MD | Chris Basham | ||
| MD | Allan | MD | John Fleck | ||
| S2 | MD | Abdoulaye Doucoure | MD | Oliver Norwood | |
| S3 | MD | James Rodriguez | MD | Ben Osborn | |
| FD | Dominic Calvert-Lewin | FD | David McGoldrick | ||
| FD | Richarlison | FD | Daniel Jebbison | ||
| Substitute | Substitute | ||||
| S1 | MD | Gylfi Sigurdsson | |||
| S2 | MD | Andre Gomes | |||
| S3 | WR | Bernard | |||
| Manager | Manager | ||||
| Carlos Ancelotti | Paul Heckingbottom | ||||